In R. v. Trader Corporation, the Ontario Small Claims Court found that a termination provision in an employment contract was unenforceable because its wording created ambiguity about the employee’s termination entitlements.
The decision is important for Ontario employees because an unenforceable termination clause may mean that an employee is entitled to reasonable notice at common law rather than being limited to the termination entitlements set out in the employment contract.
Background
The employee worked for a company in the automotive industry and was terminated without cause. The parties agreed that the termination was without cause, but disagreed about whether the termination provision in the employee’s employment contract was enforceable and, consequently, how much notice or pay in lieu of notice the employee was entitled to receive.
The employment agreement stated that, upon termination without cause, the employee would receive notice or pay in lieu of notice, severance pay if owing, accrued vacation pay and “any other compensation or benefits” required by Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 (“ESA”).
A separate paragraph stated that the employee’s group insurance benefits would continue for the period required by the ESA, “provided such coverage is available from the insurer.”
Why Was the Termination Clause Unenforceable?
The Court found that the two provisions, when read together, created ambiguity about the employee’s termination entitlements.
One concern was the use of the general phrase “any other compensation or benefits.” Although the agreement specifically referred to notice, severance pay and vacation pay, it did not clearly identify the other forms of compensation or benefits to which the employee could be entitled.
The following paragraph specifically addressed group insurance benefits. The Court found that reading the provisions together could reasonably suggest to an employee that “any other compensation or benefits” meant only group insurance benefits. This could leave the impression that other entitlements, such as pension, life insurance or retirement savings benefits, would not be provided.
The Court also took issue with the statement that group insurance benefits would continue only “provided such coverage is available from the insurer.” The wording suggested that the employee’s entitlement could depend on whether the insurer continued coverage, even though the employee could still have an entitlement if the coverage itself could not be continued.
The Court concluded that the termination provisions contained sufficient confusion and ambiguity that they did not provide the level of clarity required for employees to understand their termination entitlements.
General ESA Language Did Not Save the Termination Clause
The employment contract also contained language stating that future amendments to the ESA would be incorporated into the agreement and that the employee would not receive additional payments or notice beyond the entitlements provided under the ESA.
The Court found that this general language did not resolve the problems with the termination provision itself.
For employees, this is significant because the inclusion of general language stating that an employment contract will comply with the ESA does not necessarily mean that a termination provision is enforceable. The specific wording of the termination clause must still be considered.
The Employee Was Awarded Common Law Reasonable Notice
Because the termination provision was unenforceable, the employee was entitled to reasonable notice at common law rather than being restricted to the contractual termination provision.
The employee sought four months’ notice, while the defendant argued that two months was reasonable. The Court ultimately determined that 10 weeks of reasonable notice was appropriate. Because the employee had already received two weeks, the employee was entitled to an additional eight weeks.
This distinction can be important following a termination. Minimum statutory termination entitlements under the ESA and reasonable notice at common law are not the same. Depending on the circumstances, an employee who is not bound by an enforceable contractual limitation may have a greater entitlement at common law.
Did the Non-Compete Clause Affect the Notice Period?
The employee argued that a non-compete provision in the employment contract should support a longer notice period because it restricted the employee’s ability to seek new employment.
The Court was not satisfied that the evidence established that the non-compete clause actually affected the employee’s job search.
For employees, this aspect of the decision demonstrates the importance of evidence showing how a contractual restriction actually affected efforts to obtain comparable employment. The existence of a restrictive covenant alone may not establish that it made the employee’s job search more difficult.
Mitigation After Termination
The employee received another job offer but declined it because the employee preferred a remote or hybrid position in order to assist with a family caregiving responsibility.
The Court found that there was insufficient evidence explaining why alternative arrangements were unavailable.
Employees claiming wrongful dismissal damages generally have a duty to take reasonable steps to mitigate their losses by seeking comparable employment. Where an employee declines an employment opportunity, the circumstances surrounding that decision may therefore become relevant to the amount of damages ultimately awarded.
Was the Employee Entitled to a Bonus?
The employee also sought compensation for a bonus calculated at 4% of salary, arguing that the bonus was an integral part of the employee’s compensation.
The Court declined to award the bonus because there was insufficient evidence establishing that it formed an integral part of the employee’s compensation. In particular, the Court noted the lack of testimony concerning the role of the bonus in the employee’s overall compensation.
The decision highlights the importance of evidence when claiming compensation for bonuses or other forms of variable remuneration during a reasonable notice period. The existence of a bonus program does not necessarily establish that a particular bonus amount will form part of wrongful dismissal damages.
How Were Pension and Benefits Treated?
The parties agreed that pension and benefits had a value equal to 10% of the employee’s salary. Of that amount, 3% represented the employee’s own contribution.
The Court deducted the employee contribution and accounted for the two weeks that had already been paid, awarding compensation based on the employer-paid portion for the additional notice period.
The employee also sought compensation for parking, gym and wellness expenses. Those claims were rejected because the expenses had not actually been incurred and were treated as reimbursements rather than compensation that increased the employee’s overall remuneration.
Damages for an Inaccurate Record of Employment
The defendant also issued an inaccurate Record of Employment (“ROE”) and did not correct it promptly. The error caused difficulties for the employee when attempting to obtain Employment Insurance benefits.
The Court awarded the employee $750 in damages relating to the inaccurate ROE and the resulting inconvenience. However, the Court also noted that the employee had provided limited evidence about the damages caused by the error.
This part of the decision demonstrates why employees should keep records of problems caused by an incorrect ROE, including delays in receiving EI benefits, communications concerning corrections and any resulting financial consequences.
Key Takeaways for Employees
Termination clauses must be clear. Employees should be able to understand what compensation and benefits they will receive if their employment is terminated. Ambiguous wording can affect whether a contractual limitation on termination entitlements is enforceable.
Benefit language can be important. Wording that appears to make an employee’s entitlement dependent on whether an insurer continues coverage may raise concerns about whether the provision properly preserves the employee’s minimum statutory entitlements.
General references to ESA compliance may not correct problematic wording. A contract may state that the employee will receive everything required by the ESA, but the specific language of the termination provision must still comply with minimum employment standards.
An unenforceable termination clause may result in a greater notice entitlement. Where an employment contract does not validly limit an employee’s termination entitlements, the employee may be entitled to reasonable notice at common law.
Evidence matters when claiming additional damages. Claims involving bonuses, restrictive covenants, mitigation, benefits or problems with an ROE will depend on the particular circumstances and the evidence available.
Reviewing a Termination Clause After Dismissal
Employees should not assume that the termination provision in their employment contract necessarily determines what they are owed after being dismissed. The wording of the clause, the employee’s compensation and benefits, and the circumstances of the termination can all affect the employee’s entitlements.
An employment lawyer can review an employment agreement and termination package to determine whether a termination provision is enforceable and whether the employee may be entitled to additional notice or compensation.
Contact Monkhouse Law Employment Lawyers for a free 30-minute phone consultation.